Russian Orthodox Church

Official website of the Moscow Patriarchate

Русская версияУкраинская версияМолдавская версияГреческая версияАнглийская версия

Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk: Constantinople’s attempt to introduce papal power in the Orthodox Church has led to a schism of world Orthodoxy

Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk: Constantinople’s attempt to introduce papal power in the Orthodox Church has led to a schism of world Orthodoxy
Version for print
28 June 2021 year 12:43

The ever more insistent statements made by representatives of the Patriarchate of Constantinople on a radical “rapprochement” between the Orthodox Church and the Catholic Church, on a possibility for their forthcoming unification make it necessary to pay special attention to the content of the Orthodox-Catholic dialogue held in the last decades and to issues that divide the Orthodox and Catholics.

Touching upon this topic on the air of the Church and the World program, chairman of the Department for External Church Relations of the Moscow Patriarchate Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk, mentioned, among other issues of the dogmatic nature, the issues of the procession of the Holy Spirit and the veneration of the Most Holy Mother of God “Who is venerated in the both traditions but differently.

As His Eminence noted, the principal dividing issue is the authority of the Pope in the Church: “We cannot accept such a model of church order as to have one man who is considered to be infallible, who will have power over all the church Councils. We speak of the Church as Catholic and Apostolic. Under catholicity we understand what in the secular language could be called the collective consciousness of the Church: in our Local Churches, the Patriarch is accountable to the Bishops’ Council, rather than the Bishops’ Council is accountable to the Patriarch”.

There are many other dividing points that have accumulated for almost a millennium-long history of the separate existence of the Orthodox and Catholics, the DECR chairman underlined.

“It is necessary to make a rational assessment of the differences, and we are ready to discuss them within the Orthodox-Catholic dialogue, but not a dialogue that is actually turned into manipulation”, Metropolitan Hilarion said stating, “What Constantinople was engaged in the Orthodox-Catholic dialogue in the last years was an attempt to manipulate Local Orthodox Churches with the aim to recognize the model in which the Patriarch of Constantinople would receive some exclusive powers”. 

“From my point of view, the policy pursued by Constantinople in this dialogue was not aimed to achieve unification of the Orthodox and Catholics but by borrowing the Catholic model to create the same model in the Orthodox Church”, he stressed, “in other words, to make us agree to the appearance of a certain infallible ‘Pope’ who would make unilateral decisions with all of us having to obey him. In our Orthodox Church, there has never been anything like this, thank God, and I believe will never be”.

As Metropolitan Hilarion pointed out, “This misshapen attempt of Constantinople to introduce the papal power in the Orthodox Church has already led to a schism in the world Orthodoxy”.

DECR Communication Service/

Version: Russian, Greek

Materials on the theme

Metropolitan Hilarion of Budapest and Hungary: Vatican concedes to liberals on the issue of same-sex couples [Interview]

Metropolitan Jonathan of Tulchyn and Bratslav characterized the words of Patriarch Bartholomew, who condemned the confessional feat of the Ukrainian hierarchs, as blasphemous

Metropolitan Hilarion of Budapest and Hungary: Constantinople's claims are getting bolder [Interview]

Metropolitan Daniel of Vidin: the faithful of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church are enduring violence owing to their faith

Representatives of the Russian Orthodox Church participated in a meeting of the Strategic Vision Group "Russia - Islamic World" in Kazan

DECR Chairman arrives in Kazan and meets with head of the Republic of Tatarstan

DECR Chairman takes part in the forum of religious leaders in Azerbaijan

Metropolitan Anthony of Volokolamsk visited the Cathedral of the Holy Myrrh-bearing Women in Baku

Metropolitan Hilarion of Budapest and Hungary: Vatican concedes to liberals on the issue of same-sex couples [Interview]

Synodal Biblical-Theological Commission meets for plenary session

DECR chairman meets with Archbishop Filippo Santoro of Taranto

Prof Dr Thomas Bremer: Freedom of faith stipulates for non-interference of state in ecclesiastical affairs

Lectures on Orthodox ecclesiology held in Belarusian Exarchate’s dioceses

Archbishop Theodosius of Sebastia visited the Russian Ecclesiastical Mission

Patriarch Kirill gives his blessing to offering up fervent prayers for archpastors and clerics of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church striving to preserve church unity

Circular letter of the Moscow Patriarchate Chancellor on prayers for hierarchs and clerics of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church held prisoners [Documents]

Information on violations of the rights of believers of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church has been submitted to the German Bundestag

His Holiness Patriarch Kirill addressed the blatant examples of pressure on the Ukrainian Orthodox Church

The largest foreign diocese of Serbian Church condemns persecution of Ukrainian Orthodox Church by Kiev regime

Meeting of the DECR Chairman with His Beatitude Patriarch Theophilos III of Jerusalem took place

Sisters of Puhtica convent address Estonian Council of Churches with an open letter concerning pressure put on the abode

Primate of the Malankara Church of India is awarded the Russian Orthodox Church’s Order of Glory and Honour

Our Churches and our peoples have undergone many trials. Catholicos-Patriarch Mar Awa III on the Assyrian Church of the East and its ties with Russia [Interview]